SEGH Articles

A human health risk assessment framework to improve the management of potentially toxic elements in informally recycled waste electronic and electrical equipment (WEEE)

04 February 2019
Dr Alessandra Cesaro, University of Salerno and Professor Andrew Hursthouse, University of the West of Scotland assess the human health risk of potentially toxic elements in informally recycled waste electronic and electrical equipment (WEEE)

Members of the EU COST Action ES140 ReCreew (http://www.recreew.eu/) have recently completed review studies which provide an assessment of the potential hazard from the informal recycling of WEEE. These activities include manual handling, sorting, component removal, crushing and grinding as well as burning and acid leaching, generate situations around the world where both operators and the wider community are exposed to emissions and residues from these activities. Substances released include a wider range of metallic elements and organic compounds form the component plastics and as a result of heating (burning or melting). Much of the WEEE collected in Europe is destined for third countries and these markets show quite dynamic changes, particularly with recent restrictions on waste import to China. 

The variability of physical and compositional characteristics and rapid growth in WEEE production creates an enormous challenge to establish appropriate methods of handling materials – particularly in the informal sector. ReCreew was concerned that the diverse methods of handling were difficult to assess systematically from a human health risk. Consequently, they embarked on a systematic study of the compositional variation and model processes to see whether there was an opportunity to provide some basis for assessment.

By using knowledge of the compositional features of individual printed circuit boards in WEEE components, an assessment based on theoretical inhalation route, ranked components on their basis of potential harm form a substance weighted perspective. This identified individual groups of components – with the top PCB (printer) nearly 4 times more hazardous than the second place (mobile phone) (Cesaro et al, 2018). Establishing the basis for prioritisation in health protection. Subsequently, a “Shrinking-Core” combustion model was used to look at emissions of metals and organic compounds (dioxins/furans) during open burning practice.  Based on mass weighted toxicity assessment, this clearly identified open burning of cables above computer and mobile phone PCBs (Cesaro et al, 2019).

These early assessments direct research to further develop realistic datasets for compositional variation of WEEE and in producing pragmatic guidance to engage with informal recycling communities and we hope to open the wider debate on resource recovery in the informal sector.


 

Cesaro, A, Belgiorno, V, Vaccari, M, Jandric, A, Chung, TD, Dias, MI, Hursthouse, A & Salhofer, S 2018, 'A device-specific prioritization strategy based on the potential for harm to human health in informal WEEE recycling' Environmental Science and Pollution Research, vol 25, no. 1, pp. 683–692. DOI: 10.1007/s11356-017-0390-7

Cesaro, A, Belgiorno, V, Gorrasi, G, Viscusi, G, Vaccari, M, Vinti, G, Jandric, A, Dias, MI, Hursthouse, A & Salhofer, S 2019, 'A relative risk assessment of the open burning of WEEE' Environmental Science and Pollution Research (accepted, in press).

Keep up to date

Submit Content

Members can keep in touch with their colleagues through short news and events articles of interest to the SEGH community.

Science in the News

Latest on-line papers from the SEGH journal: Environmental Geochemistry and Health

  • Earthworms and vermicompost: an eco-friendly approach for repaying nature’s debt 2020-01-23

    Abstract

    The steady increase in the world’s population has intensified the need for crop productivity, but the majority of the agricultural practices are associated with adverse effects on the environment. Such undesired environmental outcomes may be mitigated by utilizing biological agents as part of farming practice. The present review article summarizes the analyses of the current status of global agriculture and soil scenarios; a description of the role of earthworms and their products as better biofertilizer; and suggestions for the rejuvenation of such technology despite significant lapses and gaps in research and extension programs. By maintaining a close collaboration with farmers, we have recognized a shift in their attitude and renewed optimism toward nature-based green technology. Based on these relations, it is inferred that the application of earthworm-mediated vermitechnology increases sustainable development by strengthening the underlying economic, social and ecological framework.

    Graphic abstract

  • Plasticizers and bisphenol A in Adyar and Cooum riverine sediments, India: occurrences, sources and risk assessment 2020-01-23

    Abstract

    Adyar and Cooum, the two rivers intersecting Chennai city, are exposed to serious pollution due to the release of large quantities of dumped waste, untreated wastewater and sewage. Sediments can act as repository for emerging organic contaminants. Hence, we have monitored the occurrence and risk associated with plasticizers [six phthalic acid esters (PAEs), bis(2-ethyl hexyl adipate) (DEHA)] and bisphenol A (BPA) in surface riverine sediments of Adyar and Cooum rivers from residential/commercial, industrial and electronic waste recycling sites. Σ7plasticizers (PAEs + DEHA) in the Adyar riverine sediment (ARS) and Cooum riverine sediment (CRS) varied between 51.82–1796 and 28.13–856 ng/g, respectively. More than three-fourth of Σ7plasticizers came from bis(2-ethylhexyl) phthalate (DEHP), in accordance with the high production and usage of this compound. BPA varied between 10.70–2026 and 7.58–1398 ng/g in ARS and CRS, respectively. Average concentrations of plasticizers and BPA were four times higher in electronic waste (e-waste) recycling sites when compared with industrial and residential/commercial sites. BPA and DEHP showed a strong and significant correlation (R2 = 0.7; p < 0.01) in the e-waste sites thereby indicating common source types. Sites present at close proximity to raw sewage pumping stations contributed to 70% of the total BPA observed in this study. For the derived pore water concentration of plasticizers and BPA, the ecotoxicological risk has been found to be higher in ARS over CRS. However, sediment concentrations in all the sites of ARS and CRS were much below the recommended serious risk concentration for human (SRChuman) and serious risk concentration for ecotoxicological (SRCeco).

  • Distribution of metal(loid)s in particle size fraction in urban soil and street dust: influence of population density 2020-01-18

    Abstract

    Assessment of street dust is an invaluable approach for monitoring atmospheric pollution. Little information is available on the size distribution of contaminants in street dusts and urban soils, and it is not known how the population density would influence them. This research was carried out to assess the size distribution of trace metal(loid)s in street dust and urban soil, and to understand how population density might influence the size-resolved concentration of metal(loid)s. Three urban areas with a high, medium and low population density and a natural area were selected and urban soil and street dust sampled. They were fractionated into 8 size fractions: 2000–850, 850–180, 180–106, 106–50, 50–20, 20–10, 10–2, and < 2 µm. The concentration of Pb, Zn, Cu, Cd, Cr, Ni, As, and Fe was determined, and enrichment factor and grain size fraction loadings were computed. The results indicated that the concentration of Pb, Zn, Cu, Cd, and Cr was highly size dependent, particularly for particles < 100 µm, especially for street dust. Low concentrations of Ni and As in street dust and urban soil were size and population density independent. Higher size dependency of the metals concentration and the higher degree of elemental enrichment in the street dust fractions than the urban soils indicate higher contribution of human-induced pollution to the dust. Findings also confirm the inevitability of size fractionation when soils or dusts are environmentally assessed, particularly in moderately to highly polluted areas. Otherwise, higher concentrations of certain pollutants in fine-sized particles might be overlooked leading to inappropriate decisions for environmental remediation.